Vandemataram song. Set to the raga Desh.

The arohana or ascend has the N3 swara. When C is the Sa, the B note.

In the avarohana, N2 swara, the Bb note is used.

Some parts of the song have phrases with G and B note in it, often leading to the higher C note, the Sa.

Other parts of the raga or song can have phrases like p n2 d2 p (notes: G Bb A G). The presence of the G and the Bb notes gives us the chord option of G minor.

There are other ragas and songs, where the G3 and G2 are used. Sahana or Madhyamavathi for example. Kadhal rojave or thumbi vaa for example – which I have played using the D and Dm chords.

Assume one of the notes as the main scale and consider the other as extra. For example, in the case of Vandemataram, consider it as a scale with the B note, while Bb rule is observed in the descend. Of course, with time, you can have a better feel for the raga and scale and accept it as a whole with all its differences!

Beauty and freedom enters through those changes we allow.

Indian guitar, carnatic, rhythm and chords, finding chords, playing by ear etc(Click to see)
Free resources at